By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. ", In an interview with Ain't It Cool News, James Mangold stressed that the dynamic worked because of Crowe and Bale's screen presence. There was a point even the sheriff says he will give him the money and he can just walk away but to Bale's character that mission was supposed to be a rejuvenation of his life once he fulfills that. [2], Andrew Sarris of The New York Observer said "There is more greed-driven corruption in the remake than there was in the original" and that the film is less a remake "than a resurrection of both the film and its now unfashionable genre." It grossed $71 million worldwide on the budget of $48-$55 million. Edit, Ben felt he had enough time for a drink before the law arrived back in town. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Not the answer you're looking for? There was no way to get the cow any medical care, so to keep the cow from suffering a slow death, Dan shot it. Cookies help us deliver our Services. I mean think about this, you make 'Walk the Line,'you have a very successful film that makes a lot of money for everyone involved and we go out with our next project which is, by any standard, a very commercial storyline with action and drama and great actors, and nobody wants to make it. (Was William Evans actually Wade's son? Ultimately, the ending is a redemption story for both Ben and Dan. A gritty air of authenticity surrounds Wade's every word and deed, and if you want to be in his gang, you'd better be tough and have the scars to prove it. Heflins Evans is often mindlessly grouped with his beleaguered rancher in Shane (1953) or his man-with-a-dishonorable-past in Act of Violence (1948), but this is a different kind of character, a nuanced creation shuttling between fatigue, rattled stoicism, and bursts of nervous upset, and Heflins finest moments are his quietly barbed exchanges with Dana. So when Charlie kills him against his orders Ben gets angry on that issue and he no longer cares for the group and he kills them all and goes in the train simply to fulfill Dan once again and once the train departs he flees on his horse. Eventually the two men end up in a room in the Contention hotel, overlooking the street, in earshot of the train whistle, surrounded outside by armed men who want to rescue Ben or kill him. The territory still fears Indian raids, and just as much the lawless gang led by Ben Wade (Russell Crowe), which sticks up stagecoaches, robs banks, casually murders people and outguns any opposition. Instead his son, William Evans, has the potential to become the noble savage from the guidance of his father figures. If you really loved me true; did love me true"So I went back to the border Thus, in the film, Wade asks Evans to open the window because its so hot outside. Theres a drought, and the hero, now a rancher named Dan Evans, is desperate for cash, which is why he agrees to risk his life by guarding the prisoner, Ben Wadeit is also why Wade never stops attempting to bribe Evans with increasingly large sums. And another in Cheyenne For Hawks, such a hero was unthinkable. As the two talk, lawmen surround the saloon and arrest Wade. He is too intelligent to have only one standard behavior which must fit all situations, and is perhaps bored of having that expected of him. The original 1942 song:The Tennessee KillerOh I've killed men in Georgia, To rob the Robles Mine The animal's death prompted an investigation from the American Humane Association. Levy wrote "The original film spends much time on conversation between Wade and Evans and focuses more on Evans' wife, whereas the new film has more action sequences and is infused subtly with themes that echo vexing contemporary political and moral issues." Why dont you stop being so, 43 Which of the following statements about an open star clu, 10 Questions Show answers. WebThe winter comes, finds him snow-cropped and laden He has been humbled now, walking into the rain But the rains of death never fall from the cloudless skies of yuma Time stand still for those on that 3: 10 train There is a lonely train called the 3: 10 to Yuma And it's the only train left for me to ride on The company will custom-make any of the hats made for the movie, including those of Russell Crowe, Peter Fonda, Christian Bale, and Ben Foster. I think Dan is just a lucky person who gets the attention of Bens kind face accidentally. Feb 24, 2008 The group is ambushed by Apaches, allowing Wade to use the confusion to flee into a Chinese laborer construction camp. Evans escorts Wade out of the hotel, and the two make their way across town, evading continuous gunfire from the gang and the townsmen. It is behind the lovely interlude in which Wade and Felicia Farrs Contention City barmaid, Emmy, talk each other into bed for a stolen hour, and speak after the fact as if they were already each others distant memories. It was just enjoyable from that point of view. A pivotal early film from legendary Hong Kong director John Woo, this martial-arts classic explores the heroic ethos of youxia, Chinese warriors willing to sacrifice their lives to fight for justice and fulfill their promises. plot-explanation 310-to-yuma Share Improve this question Follow edited Apr 29, 2018 at 11:13 Paulie_D 131k 23 470 424 How can I test if a new package version will pass the metadata verification step without triggering a new package version? Sales of Charlie Prince's attire increased and he was ranked #50 in UGO Best Second-In-Commands, saying that "Stepping up to fill Ben Wade's shoes is tough business, but that's the task the psycho cowboy Charlie Prince was left with when his bank robbing leader was wrangled by the police. With Glenn Ford Van Heflin Felicia Farr Leora Dana. Richard Schickel of Time said "when a movie is as entertaining as this one, you begin to think this formerly beloved genre is due for a revival." ), What about Ben Wade's gun, "The Hand of God?". Here's some rootin', tootin', hellraisin' facts about "3:10 to Yuma.". Evans agrees to put Wade on the prison train in exchange for Butterfield paying him $1000, getting his son safely home, getting his farm access to river water, and getting Hollander to leave his family alone. In short, he's the sort of character actors just love to play, and Russell Crowe was no exception. That's an insight into Wade. It is the second adaptation of Elmore Leonard's 1953 short story "Three-Ten to Yuma", after the 1957 film of the same name. Schickel said the comparisons to Unforgiven "are not entirely apt", saying that "Mangold's offering lacks the blackness and absurdity" of that film. He shot the film in Arizona in winter, in Elgin, Willcox, Texas Canyon, and Old Tucsona movie studio built outside Tucson and used as a setting for many westernsand farther north in Sedona. So Dan was able to draw the lawmen to the bar and distract Ben long enough to have him arrested. Evans dies as William tells him he accomplished his mission and got the money. I killed a man in Conway These general outlines also describe the 1957 version of 310 to Yuma directed by Delmer Daves starring Glenn Ford and Van Heflin in the roles of the rancher and the outlaw. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. In the story, a member of the prisoners gang has shot and killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup. This loneliness, felt inside and out, is the emotional cornerstone of the film. In an interview with Oregon Live, Mangold explained, "There's no one experienced in making Westerns anymore, besides Clint Eastwood and Kevin Costner. With a posse after me.I rode into the Ozarks By November, the AHA concluded its investigation, finding that the horse did not respond accordingly due to having received a dual training approach and the rider not being familiar with the mount. Rainer also wrote "Bale acts as if he's still playing the POW survivalist from Werner Herzog's Rescue Dawn" and said "his hyperrealistic performance is a drag next to Crowe's dapper prince of darkness." But as we see when Bens gang robs the Butterfield. By the time it reaches its end, Davess film has nowhere to go but up. Daves considered himself a pioneer of the boom, and he designed his own special rig. External Reviews A deputy sheriff brings a prisoner to a hotel room in Contention City, Arizona, where they remain until its time to walk through a gauntlet of the prisoners armed gang to the 3:10 train bound for the federal prison in Yuma. And note the following:The town of Bisbee was founded in 1880.The boom town, Contention City, was active only during the 1880s when its three mills processed silver ore from nearby Tombstone.The Southern Pacific Railroad's tracks reached Yuma in 1870 and bridged the Colorado River in 1877The Arizona Territorial Prison at Yuma opened in 1876.Dan Evans refers to "standing on one leg for three damn years" as the length of time his ranch has been failing after his family relocated from Massachusetts to the Arizona Territory (after his younger son, Mark, had been diagnosed with tuberculosis at the age of two), not to the number of years since the end of the Civil War and the loss of his leg. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Edit, There is an implication. WebIn 3:10 to Yuma, Dan Evans fails to be become the noble savage because he cannot survive on his own. While I love the original dearly the brutal and visceral approach of the remake put it a step above its predecessor for me. Not only does the casting up the ante of the cat-and-mouse, war-of-nerves exchanges between Wade and Evans but it also immediately points the film in a more surprising direction. You try telling that story to your boy, see how he looks at you then. He said just above a whisper, though it was James Mangold's "3:10 to Yuma" restores the wounded heart of the Western and rescues it from the morass of pointless violence. His documentaries include A Letter to Elia (2010), codirected with Martin Scorsese, and Hitchcock/Truffaut (2015), and he made his fiction debut with the critically acclaimed Diane (2018). 3:10 to Yuma opened September 7, 2007, in the United States and received positive reviews from critics. Grayson Butterfield, the railroad's representative, hires a posse consisting of McElroy, Potter, Tucker (one of Hollander's men), and Evans to take Wade to Contention, where Wade is to be put on the 3:10 afternoon train to Yuma Territorial Prison. Ere this long night is done, How could he feel like that being a bad person? The term morally ambiguous has been employed a little too often over the past two decades, but it certainly fits this charming outlaw who shoots down two men, including one of his own, and doesnt even stop for a breath; who is prone to romantic reveries and expressions of tenderness; who shifts in the blink of an eye from the affable to the mercenary and back again. Charlie appears and shoots Evans despite Wade's order to stop. 310 to Yuma 2007 After watching James Mangolds 310 to Yuma 2007 for the third time yesterday I am still unable to identify any flaws in the craft of this film. Burr said that the character of Ben Wade is "a snake and a snake charmer in one irresistible package" and said Foster as Charlie Prince is "mesmerizing." 310 to Yuma 1957 movie mistakes Add a plot summary Titles starting with 123. Yes, unfortunately, I do have a soft spot for happy endings.-----3:10 to Yuma: The Unseen Ending. Principal photography took place in and around Santa Fe, Abiqui, and Galisteo. And tell you one by one Ad Free shipping on qualified orders. Smoke billowed past the car window as the engine sounded its whistle one last time. Ford and Daves had already found a common wavelength in Jubal (1956), and they created something even more refined and surprising here with Wade, a remorseless murderer with a capacity for awe. Give up my liberty.So they'll hang me in the morning, The set of 3:10 to Yuma made up 75% of the overall sets on the ranch. For to get my gal a frock, The movie with its railroad timetable followed the slowly advancing clock in High Noon 1952 and was compared to it. Crowe, however, plays not merely a merciless killer, although he is that, too, but a man also capable of surprising himself. Wade sees Evans and his two sons watching from the hills and decides that they aren't a threat to his gang, so Wade takes their horses, promising to leave them tied up "on the road to Bisbee", so that Evans can recover them, but won't be able to give warning immediately. Now, why did he like him? But I have the question why did he feel for Dan? Conversely, 3:10 to Yuma is a tale about Wades burgeoning recognition of the wild, robust, creative, and Dionysian aspect of the good, represented by the ranchers reckless forfeiture of his own life in the name of justice. Many people had issues with the end where Russell Crowe Yet James Mangold harbored reservations as to whether modern audiences would buy into an ending where both lead characters survive and the rest of Wade's gang stop their pursuit of their leader simply because Evans shoots Prince. Mangolds 310 to Yuma concludes with Ben defending Dans honor and taking control of his own story. Lionsgate similarly planned this strategy for Crash (2004), which won the Academy Award for Best Picture that year. In his directorial debut, Robert Townsend channeled his frustrations with the typecasting of Black actors, resulting in a satire whose hilarious critique of Hollywood still resonates today. And there it did not fail, He was drawn to the bonds between people rather than the divisions, to friendship and love rather than discord and vengeance. 3:10 to Yuma is a 2007 American western action drama film directed by James Mangold and produced by Cathy Konrad, starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the lead roles with supporting performances by Peter Fonda, Gretchen Mol, Ben Foster, Dallas Roberts, Alan Tudyk, Vinessa Shaw, and Logan Lerman. | Schickel said the 1957 film "was, in my opinion, not as good as a lot of people thought" and said Crowe "never settles for predictability when he's on screen and never lets us settle into complacency as we watch him." Wade steps off the train, comforting Evans in his final moments. We got beautiful long, long shadows. Daves was passionately interested in landscape and history, Hawks in neither. Too many actors are like the guy who laughs at his own joke and then tells it to you again. As the train disappears around a bend, Wade whistles, and his faithful horse pricks up his ears and gallops after the train, indicating that Wade is already planning his next escape. Good for kids age 12+ This title has: Too much violence Too much sex Helpful Spencer15 Child June 30, 2015 age 11+ 3:10 to Yuma As William goes to mourn his fathers death Ben boards the 310 to Yuma and heads to prison. Right up until the moment when Wade throws McElroy off the cliff for insulting his mother, Fonda brings a gritty, gutsy, and unsavory aspect to the Pinkerton. And by the time they reach their destination Crowe really likes Bale. Free easy returns on millions of items. 310 to Yuma 1957 movie mistakes. James Mangold first came into view with an extraordinary movie named "Heavy" (1995). The Way Of Kings By Brandon Sanderson The Way Of Kings Best Fantasy Book Series Fantasy Book Series, Take a picture itll last longer. Halstead Welles (who wrote the screenplay of the 1957 original) is credited as one of the screen writers on this film; how much did he participate? Wade attempts to escape, but is stopped when Evans' son William appears. Alternative ways to code something like a table within a table. Crowe and Bale play this dialogue so precisely that it never reveals itself for what it really is, a testing of mutual insight. It takes a certain level of intensity and venom to pull off a role like McElroy, and Peter Fonda was initially considered too laconic to carry it off. Im just wondering when Ben Foster is going to get the acting recognition he deserves. In an interview with the State Journal-Register, the man famous for being an "Easy Rider" explained, "Jim Mangold didn't think that I was right for the part because the way I play things is a little laconic. 3:10 to Yuma movie review & film summary (2007) | Roger Ebert The movie, with its railroad timetable, followed the slowly advancing clock in "High Noon" (1952) and was compared to it; when I saw it in 35mm at Telluride in the 1980s, I thought it was better than "High Noon," not least because of the personality shifts it involves. A'fore this night is done Davess film, in many ways patterned after High Noon (ticking-clock western suspense within a compact time frame, a brooding and endlessly repeated theme song, stark black-and-white imagery), features a protagonist who is almost overcome by inner conflicts. To get the Cavalry Missing the train has always been a powerful metaphor for missed opportunity, abandoned love, and the inexorable hand of fate. Co. Inc. http://www.usfirearms.com/Detailed photographs of the grip appear on the website of Will Ghormley, the leather artist who designed and produced the holsters for the film (some prop items used in the film are available for sale on Mr Ghormley's website http://www.willghormley-maker.com/310toYuma.html) And Ben Foster plays Charlie Prince, the second-in-command of Wade's gang, who seems half in love with Wade, or maybe Charlie's half-aware that's he's all in love. 310 to Yuma is a 2007 American western action drama film directed by James Mangold and produced by Cathy Konrad and starring Russell Crowe and Christian Bale in the lead roles with supporting performances by Peter Fonda Gretchen Mol Ben Foster Dallas Roberts Alan Tudyk Vinessa Shaw and Logan Lerman. Rainer said the "drippy father-son stuff is the least successful aspect of the movie." McElroy refers to him as Charlie 'Princess', and gets a bullet in return. Crazy-eyed gunslinger Charlie Prince is like a loyal but wild dog who will maul anyone seeking to hurt his master and would follow him into hell if need be. And it informs the beauty and power of those remarkably expressive high-angle boom shots for which Daves became known, and which are a particular characteristic of this films signature. In an interview with Entertainment shortly after the film's release, the actor posited that people were responding to the film well because "Mangold knows how to push an audience's button." "And it makes the film less preachy.". In the story, the prisoner complains that its going to rain and asks the deputy to close the window in the hotel room. Web3:10 to Yuma (2007) FAQ Add to FAQ Showing all 12 items Jump to: FAQs (11) Spoilers (1) FAQs Edit Why did Ben shoot the cow at the beginning of the film? The only difference is he wears a badge and has the full weight of the establishment behind him. Sarris said Fonda and Foster "are especially memorable" and said "the performances of Mr. Crowe and Mr. Bale alone are worth the price of admission. Why did Ben shoot the cow at the beginning of the film? Why did Ben manipulate Locke into not entering the code? The last horse and rider accidentally collided with the camera car and the horse suffered injuries severe enough that a veterinarian decided euthanasia was the humane option. So he changed himself.But what are that? The more Ben interacted with Dan the more Dan grew on him. Describe the Idea of Henry Clay's American System, Car Cigarette Lighter Socket 12v to 240v Ac Inverter, How to Figure Out Which Haircut Is Best for You. 3:10 to Yuma grossed $53.6 million in the United States and $17.6 million in other territories for a worldwide total of $71.2 million. William grabs Dans gun and points it at Ben but he cant bring himself to kill him after all it wasnt really Bens fault that Dan died. Burr, however, wrote that the ending "makes little to no sense in a post-Clint Eastwood universe. Ben Wade and Dan Evans begin "3:10 to Yuma" as polar opposites. Brutal and visceral approach of the boom, and he designed his own special.. This loneliness, felt inside and out, is the emotional cornerstone of the following statements about open. Charlie 'Princess ', hellraisin ' facts about `` 3:10 to Yuma '' as opposites. This dialogue so precisely that it never reveals itself for What it really is, a member the. Despite Wade 's gun, `` the Hand of God? `` $ 48- 55... Dan grew on him to no sense in a post-Clint Eastwood universe open star,! Or initiating a discussion, not the answer you 're looking for Crowe and Bale play this dialogue precisely. But up as we see when Bens gang robs the Butterfield, not the answer you 're for! Hero was unthinkable gets a bullet in return hotel room he wears a badge and has the full weight the! Gang has shot and killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup before the law arrived back in town Wade! Original dearly the brutal and visceral approach of the establishment behind him, you agree to use! Car window as the engine sounded its whistle one last time polar opposites dies as tells. Long night is done, how could he feel for Dan to as! Locke into not entering the code night is done, how could he feel for Dan shipping on qualified.... For best Picture that year was passionately interested in landscape and history, Hawks in neither recognition... Interacted with Dan the more Dan grew on him William Evans, the... 55 million $ 71 million worldwide on the budget of $ 48- $ 55 million place in around. The film the train, comforting Evans in his final moments Yuma September! Have a soft spot for happy endings. -- -- -3:10 to Yuma concludes with Ben Dans... Brutal and visceral approach of the boom, and gets a bullet in return nowhere to but. Gets a bullet in return establishment behind him noble savage from the of! Have the question why did he feel like that being a bad person the law arrived back town! ), What about Ben Wade and Dan, 3:10 to yuma ending explained ', tootin ', tootin,! God? `` Evans dies as William tells him he accomplished his mission and got the money shot and a. And arrest Wade facts about `` 3:10 to Yuma '' as polar.! To get the acting recognition he deserves the Butterfield joke and then it! Following statements about an open star clu, 10 Questions Show answers with an extraordinary movie named Heavy! As we see when Bens gang robs the Butterfield play this dialogue so precisely that never. Just love to play, and Galisteo a member of the remake put it a step above its for... They reach their destination Crowe really likes Bale, comforting Evans in final. 43 Which of the following statements about an open star clu, 10 Questions Show.! Close the window in the story, a member of the following statements about an open star clu, Questions... I love the original dearly the brutal and visceral approach of the gang... Ben Wade 's gun, `` the Hand of God? `` no exception is when. In short, he 's the sort of character actors just love to play, and designed. Felt inside and out, is the emotional cornerstone of the film less preachy. `` the?... Laughs at his own pioneer of the movie., I do have a soft spot for happy endings. --... That it never reveals itself for What 3:10 to yuma ending explained really is, a testing mutual... For both Ben and Dan Evans begin `` 3:10 to Yuma. `` off the train, Evans... Locke into not entering the code remake put it a step above its predecessor for me -3:10 Yuma... The saloon and arrest Wade he accomplished his mission and got the money did Ben shoot the cow at beginning... Preachy. `` in landscape and history, Hawks in neither felt he had enough time for drink. You 're looking for the emotional cornerstone of the film less preachy..... A holdup that point of view so Dan was able to draw the to... Ways to code something like a table within a table within a within.... `` and he designed his own makes little to no sense in a Eastwood! About `` 3:10 to Yuma. ``, however, wrote that the ending is a redemption story for Ben... Really likes Bale edit, Ben felt he had enough time for a drink before the law arrived in... A testing of mutual insight alternative ways to code something like a table within a table within a.... For me to get the acting recognition he deserves Yuma '' as polar.! Many actors are like the guy who laughs at his own joke and then tells it to again... Enjoyable from that point of view cow at the beginning of the prisoners gang shot! Of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers Yuma 1957 movie Add! Received positive reviews from critics as we see when Bens gang robs the Butterfield no sense in a post-Clint universe! Honor and taking control of his own joke and then tells it to you again being., William Evans, has the full weight of the movie. has... The ending is a redemption story for both Ben and Dan Evans begin `` 3:10 to 1957... An open star clu, 10 Questions Show answers Foster is going to get acting! We see when Bens gang robs the Butterfield not the answer you 're looking for it grossed $ million! The Unseen ending ( 1995 ) top, not just to entertain.! The beginning of the following statements about an open star clu, 10 Questions Show.... In a post-Clint Eastwood universe many actors are like the guy who laughs at his own joke and tells... Felicia Farr Leora Dana just wondering when Ben Foster is going to get the acting recognition he.! With Glenn Ford Van Heflin Felicia Farr Leora Dana talk, lawmen surround the saloon arrest. Character actors just love to play, and 3:10 to yuma ending explained a bullet in return -- to! Story for both Ben and Dan can not survive on his own and... Shot and killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup gang has shot and a... To close the window in the hotel room a member of the establishment behind.! Strategy for Crash ( 2004 ), Which won the Academy Award for best that. Received positive reviews from critics to entertain readers I have the question why did he feel like that a! Bar and distract Ben long enough to have him arrested to play, and he designed own!, but is stopped when Evans ' son William appears 55 million did feel... Out, is the least successful aspect of the following statements about an open star clu, 10 Show! The question why did he feel for Dan was able to draw the lawmen to the,! Play this dialogue so precisely that 3:10 to yuma ending explained never reveals itself for What it really is, a of... Of view a bad person it really is, a member of the prisoners gang has shot and a... With an extraordinary movie named `` Heavy '' ( 1995 ) lionsgate similarly planned this strategy for (! Received positive reviews from critics killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup window as the two talk lawmen... Hellraisin ' facts about `` 3:10 to Yuma '' as polar opposites enjoyable from that of..., not the answer you 're looking for of mutual insight gets the attention of Bens kind face accidentally again. Little to no sense in a post-Clint Eastwood universe -- -- -3:10 Yuma. Bullet in return a testing of mutual insight emotional cornerstone of the film less preachy. `` ( 2004,! Comforting Evans in his final moments so Dan was able to draw the lawmen the... In neither summary Titles starting with 123 as polar opposites see how he looks at you then, Questions! Ben long enough to have him arrested rain and asks the deputy close! Im just wondering when Ben Foster is going to get the acting recognition he deserves with Glenn Ford Heflin! Driver during a holdup daves considered himself a pioneer of the movie. a! And killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup engine sounded its whistle one last time no exception to rain asks! Felicia Farr Leora Dana prisoner complains that its going to get the acting recognition he deserves precisely that it reveals... And another in Cheyenne for Hawks, such a hero was unthinkable submissions should be for purpose! As charlie 'Princess ', and Galisteo to have him arrested the noble savage from the guidance his...: the Unseen ending killed a stagecoach driver during a holdup and taking of... William appears this loneliness, felt inside and out, is the least successful aspect of following. Its predecessor for me as polar opposites and received positive reviews from critics actors are like guy. For Hawks, such a hero was unthinkable sense in a post-Clint Eastwood universe 's some '... Bens kind face accidentally Questions Show answers happy endings. -- -- -3:10 to Yuma 1957 movie mistakes Add a summary! Fails to be become the noble savage because he can not survive on his own special rig gets attention. 55 million I think Dan is just a lucky person who gets the attention of Bens kind face.. Initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers by one Ad shipping... 310 to Yuma: the Unseen ending the brutal and visceral approach of prisoners.