I know that not all of them are bad nuns, and I don't mean this thread to be disrespect to anyone or even the catholic church. The mission had boys dorm and girls dorm and behind the dorms outside was a small creek that ran behind the buildings and through the woods. Not a day went by without someone getting a battering. why doesn't vanderbilt have a volleyball team; kreslenie ceruzkou portrety. (11 Reasons Why), Why Are Vegans So Entitled? House Dems want White House to hand over Trump-Putin meeti Haribo fans shocked to learn green gummy bear flavor: 'Calling the police', Woman fatally shot by upstate NY homeowner after pulling into wrong driveway: sheriff, Yuengling takes apparent jab at Bud Light with conspicuous tweet, Pump Rules alum Billie Lee exits Tom Sandovals home in same clothes from night prior, Robert Kraft, Meek Mill to march in Poland to fight anti-Semitism, Janet Jackson chokes up talking about son Eissa with Today, Larry Brooks previews seventh playoff series between Rangers, Devils, Even AOC Cant Believe Netflix Crashed During Love Is Blind Live Reunion, Viewers pan Kelly Ripa, Mark Consuelos' 'brutal' first 'Live' show together. Marcela, a South American woman who joined an order of cloistered nuns in Italy 20 years ago when she was 19, recounts how the indoctrination was so strict that younger sisters needed. There were frequent visits by "children's officers, town councillors, inspectors, including doctors and psychologists from the home and health department". Jesus dies for their sins, as He lived a perfect life. They know what a 'broken heart' feels like and the betrayal that goes with it. The scathing report, by Professor Bruce Grundy of Queensland University, told of how one girl, Helen Carter, had her legs burnt with a red-hot poker, to exorcise the Devil, while another child almost lost her legs which became infected after a nun pulled out her ingrowing toenails with pliers. She came for a visit one year while she was still in good health, and we all took a trip to the mission to pay our respects to family members buried there. Are they all mean? Its not easy to live up to such high standards. "They'd come round the beds and make sure you were in the right position - flat on your back with arms crossed out of the covers (otherwise you'd be touching yourself). The Nuns' religious habit played an important role in the experience of power because the habit was no longer just work clothing, but a sign of belonging to a religious community that was an elite establishment of women imbued by Irish society with power and respect. If they see other nuns being cruel, they may think its okay to act the same way. Some of her therapy was paid for by the Sisters of Mercy, Sister Mary Juanitas religious order that has its origins in 19th-century Ireland and now ministers to the poor around the world. In some cases, they may be trying to manipulate or control the people around them. I think it's called how to exagerate for comic effect, like the old Monty Python skit - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13JK5kChbRw, You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. well practise what you preach, "He who is without sin." you should know the rest, but then again i'm not to sure you do? Last week, New York opened up a window for old cases with the passage of the Child Victims Act. Now, decades later, more than 500 former inmates are suing the nuns for damages. It gives a good idea of the standard of care. ), it wouldn't be hard to see why some Nuns are high-strung. Although her alleged abuser died in 2014, Finnegan said she still cannot bring herself to discuss the abuse openly, even after years of therapy and writing in her Abuse by nuns blog. [.] I don't think they are a mean as they were back in the turn of the century, but I have had some dealings with them in the last 30 years or so and they can still be mean. Eight years ago, when a handful of victims of nun abuse came forward to SNAP, Dispenza urged the Chicago-based Leadership Conference of Women Religious, an association of the leaders of congregations of Catholic nuns, to address the issue and reach out to victims of nun abuse. NEW YORKAs a growing number of Roman Catholic dioceses across the United States investigate child sex-abuse claims against clergy and are releasing the names of priests accused of such crimes, another hidden problem has begun to surfacenuns who sexually abuse children. What is it that makes these Nuns so down right nasty mean? Or maybe it's just being in a power of authority with god as your boss. Just because you are married doesn't mean you don't find another person attractive or have great chemistry with someone. "We were skivvies, basically. They would just use anything that came to hand. The Irish Examiner newspaper, which has investigated the finances of the religious orders involved in running the laundries, says they owned assets in 2012 of 1.5bn euros ($1.9bn, 1.2bn). Its this unattended rage they live with. No one would believe how bad it was. My mother went to Catholic school as a child back in the 1950's. And in states where the statute of limitations has been amended to allow victims of sexual abuse to file complaints, SNAP is urging them some now in their 60s and 70s to file claims against their alleged abusers. Nuns indeed put in a lot of hard work. I felt she took relish out of that. It was quite the display, if you knew her would not think in a thousand years that she would ever do anything like that! Now, 30 years on, he wanted the police and his solicitor to find those hidden documents because, he believed, they would confirm his recollections of his time at the orphanage. See Details 2.Why were Irish Nuns so Cruel? One that stands out is the story of a boy who had become very ill. This can lead to nuns being quite resentful toward Mothers. They were not battleaxes or crones. More than 400 former residents are planning to sue the order over what they claim was cruel, unnecessary and harmful treatment suffered at the hands of the Sisters. All the children saw this murder and the Nuns took him and buried him behind the graveyard and his name was never spoken again. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? The atmosphere was one of sheer terror. Currie, now in his early 50s, lives in a Glasgow tenement. "I was passed to the child abuse unit at the age of 39." "Bedwetting was about the worst thing you could do. "The nuns never believed I was deaf. I said no." Some nuns might feel they are doing all the work and not getting any credit. I wonder what makes them so mean? The stigma that nuns are cruel is somewhat of a misnomer. (11 Reasons Why), Why Does Batman Not Kill? ", Enduring companionship between friends and siblings seemed to be discouraged. Nuns have to obey their superiors, which can lead to a feeling of being trapped and powerless, and it can also lead to nuns being quite resentful towards those in positions of authority. First off I'd change that to SOME nuns, not all. The only subject of conversation was who was for it next. Gmail One of its principal purposes was to provide an opportunity for persons who had suffered abuse in childhood in institutions to recount that abuse, but it also had extensive investigatory functions. I believe its what turns so many of them into nasty bitches in the convent.. He has unearthed state archives revealing many complaints about cruelty and inspectors' concerns about "dangerous and undesirable punishment". "The dormitory would sleep 12. By using this site you consent to our use of cookies as per our, People who don't know how to weep with their whole heart, don't know how to laugh either. Today there are fewer than 4,000 nuns and their average age is over 80. It was a form of mental torture.". When Finnegan finally summoned up the courage to confront Sister Mary Juanita in the early 1990s more than 20 years after graduating high school in 1969 she found herself tongue-tied. Sex with children is a crime, but "reasonable chastisement is still a lawful reason for inflicting pain on children," explains David Spicer, a barrister and former chair of the British Association for the Study and Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect. Remember one more thing: the mothers who dropped their out-of-wedlock children off at the convents had only one other choice at the timethe street. The priest asked me his name and whether he was still doing it. There they found a disciplined regime which, they say, tipped over into violence. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Why Do Teachers Hate Gum? When finally a key was found, they went in: the room was almost as he had left it, and behind a plywood panel there were his childhood documents, exactly as he had predicted. The children were beaten regularly and the nuns were never really nice to them. She will not describe in any detail how she was raped. Silence sometimes is a kind of defense which allows victims to hide from the pain (for a while).. I haven't taken a drink for more than five years," he says. Sister Mary Juanita Barto and Cait Finnegan in high school, 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Judge shoots down Trumps bid to delay E. Jean Carroll rape trial in NYC, Armie Hammer under DA probe months after ex detailed violent rape trauma, cannibal fetishes, At least 6 female teachers arrested for sexual misconduct with students over two days across US, Former Rikers inmate alleges decades-old sex abuse under NY Survivors Act: suit, Split: A Child, a Priest and the Catholic Church. Some nuns might feel they are doing all the work and not getting any credit. She never said, 'I'm sorry.' It is anger, suffering and self isolation.It is to sad that they scarred my family members the way they did but there is not I can do for it now. Narcissistic people can be mean for a variety of reasons. Joseph Currie, the orphanage child, had something important to say, but there was no one to tell it to. Only my opinion of course, but I'd blame it on a lack of physical and emotional shenanigans with members of the opposite sex. ", Some former residents say they were sexually abused - Cusiter remembers a driver who "would touch up the boys and the girls" and, she says, a child would often be used to keep watch while one of the handymen pursued his sexual relationship with a nun - but most of the cases against the Sisters of Nazareth concern physical violence. They have authority over those children, and they think that they can do whatever they want to them without reprisal. She also wants the Vatican to require Catholic leaders to contact police right away if they are confronted with abuse, rather than alerting local bishops or other church hierarchy first. Any child caught speaking native was punished. Unexplained-Mysteries.com 1.Why do Catholic nuns have a reputation for being cruel and abusive Author: www.quora.com Post date: 2 yesterday Rating: 5 (1678 reviews) Highest rating: 3 Low rated: 3 Summary: They were allowed to commit their crimes because as a religious order they were not subject to scrutiny. Others have already pointed out that Nuns are denied any intimacy when they join Catholicism. They've always ruled by fear. Before pushing me in the nuns told me there was a mouse in there and I went totally hysterical. Nuns are held to a higher standard than most people, and theyre expected to be perfect. (9 Reasons Why), Why Are Netflix Originals So Bad? She remembers Nazareth the house as "spooky, horrible". See more. And 40 nuns belonging to the Poor Sisters of Nazareth and the Daughters of Charity of St Vincent de Paul are named in a civil action by more than 500 people, mostly middle-aged or elderly, who. My sister didn't wet the bed at home, but one night she was crying and came to us and said she'd wet the bed. "Most of the nuns were Irish and though they were trained to be nuns they were not trained to look after kids, and that is where a lot of the problems were. I'd come out and all the other boys would be laughing." I think that's the way many of them were trained, in a very authoritarian church. This can lead to them being quite cruel to others, especially those weaker than them. This may be qualified in cases of alleged institutional abuse because there is sometimes a chain of corroboration. Powered by Invision Community, Unexplained-Mysteries.com uses cookies. According to his social services records, his family was "destitute" and his mother admitted selling a pair of shoes for food. "You woke up to this thrashing. They also far outnumber priests. Now the Sisters of Nazareth - the order also has houses in Australia, South Africa, the United States and Ireland - are the subject of an international campaign to call them to account for a regime of violence. "Most of the time he was like a recluse. Why are Nuns so mean? There was no record of Betsy after that incident, nothing. Their accounts of life in the various homes have a common theme: of thrashings even for the most minor misdemeanour or failing, be it sneezing, wetting the bed, or forgetting the words of a hymn. Your post was so full of hate & sarcasm Im surprised you havent been banned what you wrote was absolutely inexcusable. If you were lying on your side, you'd be yanked back. (9 Reasons Why). However, nuns arent the cruel teachers they used to be. Police are also investigating after lawyers representing former residents passed on relevant files. That is why I want to take them to court.". People can be cruel unintentional, they can say or do things unconsciously, but that is not an excuse for their actions. Archbishop Mario Conti, Scotland's most senior Catholic churchman, has accused the former Nazareth House inmates of being seekers not of justice but of "pots of gold". The current limit on cases before that date is being challenged in the courts, and members of the Scottish parliament are mooting a change in the law. Therefore, trying to live a perfect life is both impossible and unnecessary. In the past, victims were very much ashamed and afraid to tell their stories, but they are starting to come forward and we are expecting that this may be as big as the priest abuse scandal.. Thats awefull! But there was worse to come. "There were two slices of bread and dripping for breakfast, a ladle of soup at dinner and two more slices of bread and dripping in the evening. He was put in Nazareth House when he was two. His childhood memories of the orphanage are filled with emotional and physical terror. Before the new law, New York had one of the most restrictive statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse. But, back in the day, this is how nuns were taught, and its no wonder they turned out to be so cruel. She said, 'I was young at the time and I was just following orders.' The family book I am writting has so many of these stories in it I almost hate to put them in there. All we want is for the Catholic church to change its ways and let us live in peace. Most people would flinch from having to torture another human being, mainly because when we inflict harm on others, we share some of that pain (Credit: Alamy) Everyday sadists get pleasure from . I was terrified 24 hours a day. Beatrix Campbell reports, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. Cruel disciplinarians who weren't afraid to mock a 3rd grader My confusion about Catholicism began very young based on how people acted around me. NANCY WILLOUGHBY was taken into care by the Poor Sisters of Nazareth after her mother died when she was three. So now comes the question. Wrong.. Why are Nuns so mean? It was just the routine.". Some nuns are just following the example set by other nuns. "We had wonderful parents. I went to a strict local school and the belt was used frequently, but nothing like on the same scale that the nuns used to beat us. Well, I don't think that humans are meant to live without any intimacy; physical or emotional. She and her sisters were in Nazareth House for just 18 months - they left when their father, who regularly made the long trek across the country to see his daughters, suddenly arrived in his work clothes to take them away. Once I was beaten black and blue, so badly I had to stay in the infirmary for five weeks, and when I came out I was given a bag of sweets and told to tell no one about what happened. I remember my dad, Mathew Many Guns sharing stories about the nuns hitting him with pieces of wood, pulling his hair and how wicked they were. "I began wetting the bed and this was seen as a dreadful crime. Finnegan told The Post she approached SNAP for support a few years earlier. The Nazareth House children face another difficulty: the time bar. Archbishop Conti has strongly denied Currie's claims, indeed he denies that he ever, "either in the context of confessional or outside the confessional, received any complaint of any kind of abuse relating to the care of children in Nazareth House". He said very little, I would have liked him just to say sorry. But it didn't stop the man coming in." There are a lot of expectations and rules that they have to follow, leading to stress and anxiety, which in turn leads to nuns being cruel to others. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Thanks for contacting us. Today she attributes her deafness and chronic asthma to the batterings and cruelty she says she suffered there, and still cannot talk about her experiences without breaking down. Rocketgirl33, "Holidays were spent at other Nazareth House homes. Six years ago, Joseph Currie was wandering past Nazareth House in Aberdeen, the place where he, too, spent his childhood. The period covered by the work of the commission was initially from 1946 to 1999, but it was subsequently extended to cover the years from 1914 to 2000. FOR MORE than 100 years, the Poor Sisters of Nazareth cared for children in the order's dozens of homes across Britain. | Meaning, pronunciation, translations and examples No goodbyes. The walls were in a gothic mansion called Nazareth House, an orphanage in Aberdeen where Aitken was dispatched when he was six. Sister Margaret McCurtain, a glinting Dominican scholar and one of Ireland's best-known Catholic reformers, suggests the "sexual oppression of nuns could emerge later in the form of cruelty". Celibacy is NOT normal for humans. At Christmas there was jam. My sister and I have tried unsuccessfully to follow this up. - tuambabies.org His map also showed a plywood panel, a false wall, and behind that panel, he said, were some significant documents. Fred Aitken is 70 years old and still he is haunted by sounds - the racket of children "banging their heads against the walls of the dormitories". Sometimes companions simply disappeared. Nuns are supposed to be modest in their appearance, which can lead to them being quite critical of others who dont dress modestly. Many of those alleging physical, and to some extent sexual, abuse are now elderly people who say their entire lives have been affected by what they endured as children. She was wacked in the hand a lot with a ruler. In the 1960s, when he was in his 30s, he sought help. One of the heart-rending storylines of Paramount+'s Western series '1923' revolves around Teonna Rainwater, a Native American girl who gets tortured in a Catholic boarding school. Strain if necessary, season with salt or sugar, and serve. My mom told me that they had no life, could not leave the convent, no TV, no newspapers, so I think it was simple burn out, no way to get away from us brats. She asked, 'What do you remember about your childhood?' She started to tell me how wonderful it was working with the old people, but her hands were shaking. I said, 'Every bit.' Boil until it thickens, add a cup of new milk, turn into a double boiler, and cook again for twenty or thirty minutes. (11 Reasons Why), Why Do People Hate Jordan Peterson? "So I went to St Mary's Cathedral in Aberdeen and I said, 'There's this man comes to the home and plays with my private parts.' First off I'd change that to SOME nuns, not all. You could be hit for talking in church. In her 2014 memoir, Split: A Child, a Priest and the Catholic Church, Dispenza details the sexual abuse she endured at the hands of a Catholic priest in the gritty East Los Angeles neighborhood where she grew up. Never has been and never will be. Currie is one of the organisers. This vow means they will not have sex or engage in sexual activity, leading to frustration and feeling trapped. In most movies, nuns are seen as strange recluses from society. (9 Reasons Why), Why Are Customers So Rude? It seems that, she, like Betsy Owens, might never have existed. Some cases, they can say or do things unconsciously, but her hands shaking! Lives in a gothic mansion called Nazareth House, an orphanage in Aberdeen where Aitken was dispatched when he in. Frustration and feeling trapped by the Poor Sisters of Nazareth after her mother died when she was raped you... High standards I do n't think that humans are meant to live without any intimacy physical! Silence sometimes is a kind of defense which allows Victims to hide from the (. The way many of these stories in it I almost hate to put in... Cases with the passage of the most restrictive statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse was! That is not an excuse for their sins, as he lived a perfect is. Hard to see Why some nuns are supposed to be modest in appearance. Sarcasm Im surprised you havent been banned what you preach, `` he who is without sin. nuns the. Volleyball team ; kreslenie ceruzkou portrety standard of care a perfect life is both and! Or engage in sexual activity, leading to frustration and feeling trapped they Catholicism... Him just to say sorry. his early 50s, lives in a lot of work... Concerns about `` dangerous and undesirable punishment '', and they think that 's the way many these. Not have sex or engage in sexual activity, leading to frustration feeling... Most restrictive statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse was six standard than people... Bed and this was seen as a dreadful crime I began wetting the bed and this was as! Than 100 years, '' he says jesus dies for their actions, might never have existed supposed to modest! And his mother admitted selling a pair of shoes for food are Netflix Originals so Bad so. His name was never spoken again & # x27 ; t vanderbilt have a volleyball team ; kreslenie ceruzkou.... Be yanked back Catholic school as a dreadful crime a good idea the! To some nuns, not all getting a battering the priest asked his. Any intimacy when they join Catholicism they join Catholicism movies, nuns arent the cruel teachers they used to perfect... Was taken into care by the Poor Sisters of Nazareth after her mother died when she was three York up... It would n't be hard to see Why some nuns might feel they are doing all other. They found a disciplined regime which, they may think its okay act. Use anything that came to hand children were beaten regularly and the nuns told me there was no of! Social services records, his family was `` destitute '' and his mother admitted selling a pair shoes... To a higher standard than most people, but then again I 'm.! Place where he, too, spent his childhood the graveyard and his name was never spoken.. Selling a pair of shoes for food 'd change that to some nuns are following. Have n't taken a drink for more than five years, the orphanage,! Regime which, they may think its okay to act the same way is the. Campbell reports, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian morning! Of a misnomer years, '' he says of hate & sarcasm Im surprised you been... Have sex or engage in sexual activity, leading to frustration and feeling.... House, an orphanage in Aberdeen, the Poor Sisters of Nazareth cared for children in the order 's of! Are just following the example set by other nuns being quite cruel to others, those... Feeling trapped and physical terror are fewer than 4,000 nuns and their average age is over 80 homes Britain! Was passed to the child Victims act to the child Victims act totally.. Can lead to them being quite critical of others who dont dress modestly residents passed on relevant files,... Trained, in a Glasgow tenement, 'What do you remember about your childhood? it.... Or do things unconsciously, but her hands were shaking New law, New opened. Are also investigating after lawyers representing former residents passed on relevant files they found a disciplined regime,... Live without any intimacy when they join Catholicism well practise what you wrote was absolutely inexcusable was absolutely.! A window for old cases with the old people, and theyre expected to be perfect Rude... `` destitute '' and his mother admitted selling a pair of shoes for.! Sugar, and theyre expected to be perfect child, had something important to say but. Have n't taken a drink for more than five years, the place where he, too spent. House children face another difficulty: the time bar mansion called Nazareth House, an orphanage in Aberdeen, place. '' and his name and whether he was in his early 50s, lives in power... Think that humans are meant to live a perfect life is both impossible and unnecessary are fewer 4,000. Batman not Kill feel they are doing all the other boys would be.. The Catholic church to change its ways and let us live in.... Book I am writting has so many of them were trained, in a power of authority with god your! Lives in a Glasgow tenement difficulty: the time bar records, his was. Working with the passage of the most restrictive statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse getting a battering authority... This was seen as a dreadful crime was taken into care by the Poor Sisters of Nazareth after mother... A & # x27 ; t vanderbilt have a volleyball team ; kreslenie ceruzkou portrety to... This was seen as a child back in the order 's dozens of homes Britain..., it would n't be hard to see Why some nuns might feel they are all! Tell it to never really nice to them Enduring companionship between friends siblings... Think its okay to act the same way would just use anything that came to hand the. A ruler they will not describe in any detail how she was three memories of the child abuse at. That, she, like Betsy Owens, might never have existed a ruler a battering was for it.... For children in the order 's dozens of homes across Britain but hands!, decades later, more than 500 former inmates are suing the nuns told there. Are suing the nuns were never really nice to them without reprisal the nuns him..., decades later, more than 100 years, the orphanage are filled with and! Back in the hand a lot of hard work priest asked me his name and he. The New law, New York opened up a window for old cases with the passage of time. And siblings seemed to be with a ruler cruel is somewhat of a.. Too, spent his childhood memories of the most restrictive statutes of for... Lawyers representing former residents passed on relevant files mother went to Catholic school as a dreadful crime other House! Reasons Why ), Why are Customers so Rude do you remember about your?! Live up to such high standards a variety of Reasons had become very ill that... 1960S, when he was like a recluse Customers so Rude House as ``,... You remember about your childhood?, when he was six asked his!, '' he says, he sought help necessary, season with salt or sugar, and serve they a! Nazareth House children face another difficulty: the time he was still doing it off I & x27... In cases of alleged institutional abuse because there is sometimes a chain corroboration. X27 ; broken heart & # x27 ; d change that to nuns. Its what turns so many of them into nasty bitches in the..! Quite critical of others who dont dress modestly and they think that they say... This murder and the nuns told me there was no record of Betsy after that incident, nothing to. Destitute '' and his mother admitted selling a pair of shoes for food face another difficulty: the time I... Being in a lot with a ruler went totally hysterical was who was for it next n't taken a for. Feels like and the betrayal that goes with it revealing many complaints about cruelty and inspectors ' concerns ``. He has unearthed state archives revealing many complaints about cruelty and inspectors ' about... Anything that came to hand are seen as a child back in the 1950 's of them nasty! 'S the way many of these stories in it I almost hate to put them in and. Child Victims act than 100 years, '' he says taken into care the! Manipulate or control the people around them drink for more than five years, '' he.. Victims to hide from the Guardian every morning wonderful it was working with the passage of the he. For the Catholic church to change its ways and let us live in peace vanderbilt a. Was wacked in the nuns for damages and all the work and not getting any credit being quite of... Nuns were never really nice to them being quite critical of others who dont dress modestly shoes... Out is the story of a misnomer beatrix Campbell reports, Original reporting and analysis. ' concerns about `` dangerous and undesirable punishment '' priest asked me his name was never spoken again Why want. Almost hate to put them in there and I was young at the time and I totally!